About TLCTC
The Core Question
What exactly is a "cyber threat"? Despite widespread use in cybersecurity standards, frameworks, and regulations, this fundamental question remains inadequately answered. My journey began with the NIST Cybersecurity Framework, which prominently features "Cyber" in its name and explicitly requires organizations to "identify threats." Yet when I consulted the referenced NIST Special Publications for clarity, I found myself even more lost. The definitions either created circular references or fell back to traditional IT risk approaches that didn't capture the recurring patterns I'd observed over 40 years in IT and Risk Management.
The confusion deepened when examining MITRE's approach. While MITRE defines weaknesses as underlying vulnerabilities—a logical foundation—they offer no systematic categorization of generic vulnerabilities themselves. This gap became particularly evident when trying to map real-world threats to actionable controls. After analyzing major standards and regulations with "cyber" in their titles or descriptions, the pattern was clear: the cybersecurity community lacked a fundamental taxonomy for the very threats we're supposed to defend against.
The Journey
- Analyzed major cybersecurity standards and frameworks
- Identified gaps in threat categorization and definition
- Developed initial framework through thought experiment
- Validated against real-world scenarios
- Challenged and refined using AI models (LLMs and reasoners)
Key Principles
- TLCTC complements existing frameworks - it doesn't replace them
- Makes other concepts "sound" through logical foundation
- Provides clear bridge between strategic and operational security
- Offers consistent taxonomy for threat classification
Looking Forward
TLCTC challenges NIST and MITRE to evolve their approaches. While it can replace STRIDE, its primary value lies in making existing frameworks more effective through clear threat categorization and logical structure.
Continuous Evolution
The framework continues to be challenged and validated through AI models and real-world applications. Your insights and challenges are welcome to further refine and strengthen the TLCTC approach.